Adults-Only Dining at Pilar Bar

A tropical resort featuring a large pool surrounded by palm trees, lounge chairs, and buildings, with an ocean view in the background.

Item 1

Leisure & Libations

Secluded among the palm fronds, away from the sounds of kids frolicking at Tiki Beach, is an adults-only poolside oasis. Pilar Bar at the Oasis Cay pool is your place to relax in serene seclusion while sipping on a tropical concoction.

Pilar Bar is an adults-only spot serving specialty drinks right to your lounge chair or private cabana.

A resort-style swimming pool surrounded by palm trees and sun loungers, with a building and clear sky in the background.

A group of women in swimsuits and hats are enjoying drinks by a poolside, surrounded by palm trees and an umbrella.

Hours & Location

Monday - Thursday: 11:00 am - 5:00 pm
Friday, Saturday & Sunday: 11:00 am - 7:00 pm

Days and hours of operation may vary by season. For more information or assistance, please call (888) 395-5539

Select a Menu:

Starters
CHIPS AND DIP | 16
Flash Fried Salted Tortilla Chips House Made Salsa Roja, Guacamole | V
CONCH FRITTERS | 17
Arugula, lemon, key lime aioli
LOADED FRIES | 14
Beer cheese dip, chopped bacon, green onion
CHICKEN WINGS | 19
Chargrilled Finished Thai Chili, Buffalo or Honey BBQ
BASKET OF FRIES | 6
BASKET OF ONION RINGS | 10
AHI TUNA TOSTADA | 20
Crispy Corn Tortilla, Avocado Smash, Scallions, Cucumber Slaw, Unagi Sauce, Wasabi Crema, Seaweed Salad
JUMBO BAVARIAN PRETZEL | 16
Beer Cheese Dip, Chopped Bacon, Green Onion
Salads
CAESAR SALAD | 16
Parmesan Cheese, Focaccia Croutons | V
KEYS BREEZE SALAD | 19
Romaine and Spring Mix, Toasted Pine Nuts, Haas Avocado, Heirloom Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Feta Cheese, Citrus-Basil Vinaigrette
QUINOA & KALE SALAD | 19
Goat Cheese, Toasted Walnuts, Georgia Peaches, Avocado, Key Lime Vinaigrette | V
POOL SALAD | 20
Butter Lettuce Wedge, Brie Cheese, Champagne Strawberries, Candied Sliced Almonds, Aged Balsamic Vinaigrette | V
SALAD ADD ON
SUGAR CANE SHRIMP SKEWER | $7
GRILLED HERBED CHICKEN BREAST | $8
DAILY CATCH (SEARED or BLACKENED)MP SEARED AHI TUNA | $13MP
From the Docks
FISH AND CHIP | 23
Islamorada Ale Batter Fried Grouper Seasoned Fries, Tropical Cole Slaw
YELLOW FIN TUNA SANDO | 22
Seared Yellow Fin Tuna, Avocado, Alfalfa Sprouts, Tomato, Applewood Bacon, Marble Rye
BLACKENED FISH SANDO | 24
Blackened Local Catch, Leaf Lettuce, Tomato, Red Bermuda Onion, Housemade Remoulade, Poppy Seed Kaiser Bun
SHRIMP TACOS | 20
Blackened Gulf Shrimp, Citrus Slaw, Cotija Cheese, Fresno Chile, Cilantro Pesto, Corn Chips, Salso Roja
STREET TACOS | 18
Blackened Mahi Mahi, Cilantro-Lime Red Cabbage, Cotija Cheese, Pickled Fresno Chile, Flash Fried Corn Chips and Housemade Salsa Roja
Sliders
COCONUT LOBSTER | 21
Sweet Chile Pesto, Frisee, Remoulade Sauce
BEER CHEESEBURGER | 17
Beer Cheese, Dill Pickle, Frizzled Onions
CUBANO | 18
Roast Pork, Shaved Ham, Swiss Cheese, Dill Pickle, Potato Straws, Dijonaise
Handhelds
OLD SKOOL DOG | 14
Smoked Jalapeño Bacon, Onion, Ketchup, Yellow Mustard
FRIED CHICKEN SANDO | 18
Honey Pineapple Glaze, Pepper Jack Cheese, Crisp Leaf Lettuce, Sliced Tomato, Brioche Bun
DUCK KEY BURGER | 19
1/2 Lb Brasstown Beef Patty, Shaved Iceberg Lettuce, Sliced Beefsteak Tomato, Fried Pickles, Pepper Jack, Bourbon BBQ, Poppy Seed Kaiser Bun
ALL AMERICAN BURGER | 19
1/2 Lb Brasstown Beef Patty, Beefsteak Tomato, Red Bermuda Onion, Crisp Leaf Lettuce, Choice Of Cheese, Brioche Bun
CAPRESE SANDWICH | 18
Fresh Mozzarella Slices, Roasted Tomato, Arugula, Basil Pesto, Toasted Ciabatta Roll
POOL DOG | 15
Hass Avocado, Plum Tomato, Sweet Banana Peppers, Potato Straws, Paprika Aioli
HAWK SIGNATURE BURGER | 21
1/2 Lb Brasstown Beef Patty, Jalapeño Bacon, Cheddar Cheese Fondue, Dill Pickles, Crispy Onions, Chipotle Ketchup, Poppy Seed Kaiser Bun
BEYOND BURGER | 20
Vegetarian Burger, Sliced Haas Avocado, Beefsteak Tomato, Chipotle Ketchup, Brioche Bun
Drinks
Bottoms up With Papa
PILAR RUM RUNNER | 19 | 37 shaker | 34 refill
Papa's Pilar Blonde Rum, Papa's Pilar Dark Rum, Lime Juice, Orange Juice, Pineapple Juice, Banana Liqueur, Blackberry Liqueur
ANGRY HAWK | 17 | 35 shaker | 32 refill
Papa's Pilar Sherry Cask, Aperol, Ruby Grapefruit, Lemon Juice, Orgeat
COME TO PAPA | 17 | 35 shaker | 32 refill
Papa's Pilar Blonde Rum, Mango Puree, Pineapple Juice, Fresh Lime Juice
PAPA'S MISTRESS | 16 | 34 shaker | 31 refill
Papa's Pilar Dark, Triple Sec, Jalapeno, Lime Juice, Cranberry Juice
Sailing Close to Tiki
GOOMBAY SMASH | 15 | 33 shaker | 30 refill
Captain Morgan Coconut Rum, Captain Morgan White Rum, Tropical Fruit Juices, Mount Gay Black Rum Float
MOJITO | 19 | 37 shaker | 34 refill
Bacardi Superior Rum, Fresh Lime, Muddled Mint, Soda Splash
LIME IN THE COCONUT | 14 | 32 shaker | 29 refill
Captain Morgan Coconut Rum, Coco Lopez, Fresh Lime, Coconut Water
TIDAL WAVE | 14 | 32 shaker | 29 refill
Captain Morgan Coconut Rum, Pineapple Juice, Melon, Blue Curacao Liqueur
Three Sheets to The Wind with Hemingway
PAPA'S STORM | 18
Papa's Pilar Dark Rum, Ginger Beer, Fresh Lime Juice, Angostura Bitters
PERFECT PILAR MANHATTAN | 18
Papa's Pilar Sherry Cask, Sweet & Dry Vermouth, Angostura Bitters
FLORIDA KEYS OLD FASHIONED | 18
Papa's Pilar Dark, Muddled Orange, Angostura & Orange Bitters, Club Soda
PAPA'S DOBLE | 20
Papa's Pilar Blonde 3oz, Grapefruit Juice, Lime Juice, Simple Syrup
In Frozen Waters
ADD PAPA'S PILAR RUM FLOATER | 5
MUDSLIDE | 18
RUM RUNNER | 17
MANGO BANGO | 16
PINA COLADA | 16
STRAWBERRY DIAQUIRI | 16
NOLET'S GIN LEMONADE | 16
Bubbles & Wine
MOET ICE CHAMPAGNE BOTTLE | 125
WHITE CLAW ASSORTED FLAVORS | 8.5
Bucket of Four Claws $28
HIGH NOON ASSORTED | 8.5
Bucket of Four High Noon's $28
TERRAZAS CHARDONNAY | 13
TERALATO PINOT GRIGIO | 13
TERRAZAS CABERNET | 13
CHARLES & CHARLES ROSÉ | 13
MURPHY-GOODE PINOT NOIR | 13
Sailors Ale
CORONA | 8.5
CORONA LIGHT | 8.5
RED STRIPE | 8.5
HEINEKEN | 8.5
BLUE MOON | 8.5
GUINNESS | 8.5
YUENGLING | 8.5
60 MINUTE IPA | 8.5
COORS LIGHT | 8.5
BUDWEISER 16OZ | 8.5
BUD LIGHT 16OZ | 8.5
MILLER LITE 16OZ | 8.5
MICHELOB ULTRA 16OZ | 8.5
O'DOULS N/A | 8.5
All Day Menu

*Although every effort is made to accommodate dietary, allergen and gluten free menu items. The kitchen facility and equipment, including deep fry oils are NOT diet specific, allergen and Gluten free. Micro cross contamination may occur. Please be aware depending on the severity of your dietary, allergen and gluten restrictions, certain food eliminations and substitutions may be required. Please ask to speak to a manager if you have questions or concerns that your server cannot answer.